| How theremins sound | 19 |
| How musical saws sound, kinda | 29 |
| Hauntingly familiar | 19 |
| Hardly comforting | 17 |
| Halloween-like | 14 |
| Hackle-raising | 14 |
| Gooseflesh-raising | 18 |
| Goosebumps-evoking | 18 |
| Goosebump inducing | 18 |
| Goose-bump-inducing | 19 |
| Goose bumps-producing, maybe | 28 |
| Giving goosebumps | 17 |
| Fucked up | 9 |
| Frighteningly unnatural | 23 |
| Frighteningly strange | 21 |
| Fearfully strange | 17 |
| Fear-inspiring | 14 |
| Far from the usual | 18 |
| Far from normal | 15 |
| Far beyond unexpected | 21 |
| Evoking goose bumps, say | 24 |
| Disturbingly coincidental, say | 30 |
| Creepy and strange | 18 |
| Creeptastic | 11 |
| Creeping you out | 16 |
| Composer Menken and others | 26 |
| Chillingly uncanny | 18 |
| Chillingly strange | 18 |
| Causing goose flesh, maybe | 26 |
| Causing chills | 14 |
| Causing a chill, maybe | 22 |
| Blood-chilling | 14 |
| Beyond unexpected | 17 |
| Awfully strange | 15 |
| Astonishingly coincidental, maybe | 33 |
| Arousing goose bumps | 20 |
| Apt to frighten | 15 |
| An ___ resemblance | 18 |
| À la Poe | 12 |
| A bit spooky | 12 |
| "__, Indiana": 1990s Omri Katz sci-fi TV series | 57 |
| "___, Indiana" (short-lived NBC series of the '90s) | 65 |
| '70s pulp horror magazine | 29 |
| ''___, Indiana'' (TV program) | 45 |
| More spooky | 11 |
| More bizarre | 12 |
| More chilling | 13 |
| More spine-tingling | 19 |
| More weird | 10 |
| More strange | 12 |
| More macabre | 12 |
| More hair-raising | 17 |
| Twice as spooky | 15 |
| More uncanny | 12 |
| More inexplicable | 17 |
| More creepy | 11 |
| Weirder | 7 |
| Twice as weird | 14 |
| More unearthly | 14 |
| More mysterious | 15 |
| More freaky | 11 |
| Comparatively spooky | 20 |
| Producing more chills | 21 |
| More fantastic | 14 |
| More eldritch | 13 |
| Even more spooky | 16 |
| Spookier | 8 |
| Scarier | 7 |
| More supernatural | 17 |
| More spectral | 13 |
| More Serling-esque | 18 |
| More phantasmal | 15 |
| More like Rod Serling works | 27 |
| More haunting | 13 |
| More goosebump-inducing | 23 |
| Like haunted houses, compared to ordinary houses | 48 |
| Like haunted houses vis-Ã -vis normal houses | 46 |
| Like a haunted house vis-Ã -vis a fun house | 45 |
| Like a ghost staying at your house, as compared to a guest | 58 |
| Like "Psycho," and then some | 38 |
| Less reassuring, perhaps | 24 |
| Eliciting more goose bumps | 26 |
| Comparatively creepy | 20 |
| Most unearthly | 14 |
| Most unusual | 12 |
| Most peculiar | 13 |
| Most weird | 10 |
| Most spooky | 11 |
| Most strange | 12 |
| Halloween superlative | 21 |
| Superlatively strange | 21 |
| Spooky to the max | 17 |
| Most uncanny | 12 |
| Most inexplicable | 17 |
| Most chilling | 13 |
| Supremely spooky | 16 |
| Superlatively weird | 19 |
| Superlatively spooky | 20 |
| Most spine-chilling | 19 |
| Most macabre | 12 |