| Beyond what is natural | 22 |
| Able to creep you out | 21 |
| X-files descriptor | 18 |
| Weird, in a spooky way | 22 |
| Way weird | 9 |
| Very odd indeed | 15 |
| Unnerving | 9 |
| Unexplainable, maybe | 20 |
| Unexplainable and spooky | 24 |
| Uncanny, as a coincidence | 25 |
| TV's "___ Indiana" | 32 |
| Too weird or coincidental | 25 |
| Supernaturally strange | 22 |
| Stretched-out canal? | 20 |
| Spookish | 8 |
| Spinetingling | 13 |
| Sort of scary | 13 |
| Scarily unnerving | 17 |
| Reminiscent of an alien landscape | 33 |
| Really spooky | 13 |
| Raising goosebumps | 18 |
| Raising goose pimples | 21 |
| Pretty peculiar | 15 |
| Poe-ish | 7 |
| Poe-esque | 9 |
| Paranormal, to some | 19 |
| Other-worldly | 13 |
| Oddly familiar | 14 |
| Odd in an unsettling way | 24 |
| Oct. 31 canal? | 14 |
| Not just odd | 12 |
| Lovecraftian | 12 |
| Likely to creep one out | 23 |
| Like theremin music, often | 26 |
| Like the sound of a theremin | 28 |
| Like the "Blair Witch" forest | 39 |
| Like tales that cause goose bumps | 33 |
| Like staying in the Bates Motel | 31 |
| Like St. Elmo's fire | 24 |
| Like some similarities | 22 |
| Like some fogs | 14 |
| Like Saint Elmo's fire | 26 |
| Like Rod Serling's stories | 30 |
| Like Rod Serling tales | 22 |
| Like premonitions | 17 |
| Like Poe's work | 19 |
| Like Poe works | 14 |
| Like much of King's work | 28 |
| Like most Serling stories | 25 |
| Like many Serling stories | 25 |
| Like many Poe works | 19 |
| Like many of Dean Koontz's novels | 37 |
| Like many John Carpenter films | 30 |
| Like many an omen | 17 |
| Like many a Stephen King novel | 30 |
| Like M. Night Shyamalan movies | 30 |
| Like King's English? | 24 |
| Like King novels | 16 |
| Like John Saul novels | 21 |
| Like howls in a haunted house | 29 |
| Like horror film music | 22 |
| Like H.P. Lovecraft's stories | 33 |
| Like H. P. Lovecraft's writing | 34 |
| Like H. P. Lovecraft stories | 28 |
| Like Gothic novels | 18 |
| Like ghost sightings | 20 |
| Like déjà vu, sometimes | 29 |
| Like déjà vu | 18 |
| Like an empty ship on the sea at midnight | 41 |
| Like an empty ship at sea | 25 |
| Like a theremin's sound | 27 |
| Like a Stephen King work | 24 |
| Like a moonlit graveyard | 24 |
| Like a Koontz novel, say | 24 |
| Like a Koontz novel | 19 |
| Like a King story | 17 |
| Like a good ghost story | 23 |
| Like a ghost's howling | 26 |
| Like a foggy graveyard | 22 |
| Like a Dean Koontz novel | 24 |
| Like a Dean Koontz book | 23 |
| Like a creepy flick | 19 |
| Like a coincidence that raises the hair on the back of your neck | 64 |
| Like a coincidence that makes you go "Hmm ..." | 56 |
| Like "Twilight Zone" episodes | 39 |
| Like "The Raven" | 26 |
| Like "Night Gallery" stories | 38 |
| Like "Lost" episodes | 30 |
| Like "Halloween" | 26 |
| Like "Goosebumps" stories | 35 |
| Like "Dark Shadows" episodes | 38 |
| Like ''The X-Files'' | 36 |
| Like ''The Shining'' | 36 |
| Kinglike? | 9 |
| Kind of creepy | 14 |
| Just plain weird | 16 |
| Inspiring inexplicable fear | 27 |
| Inducing shivers | 16 |
| Inducing goose bumps | 20 |
| Inducing fear | 13 |