| Bard's 'always' | 27 |
| Ballad tag | 10 |
| Ballad follower | 15 |
| Auction suffix | 14 |
| Auction or musket ender | 23 |
| Auction finish | 14 |
| Auction extension? | 18 |
| Auction ender? | 14 |
| Auction closer | 14 |
| Auction chaser | 14 |
| Auction addition | 16 |
| At any time, to Frost | 21 |
| At any time, to a poet | 22 |
| At any time, poetically | 23 |
| At any time, in verse | 21 |
| At any time, in poetry | 22 |
| At all times, poetically | 24 |
| Always: Poet. | 13 |
| Always, to the Bard | 19 |
| Always, to Pope | 15 |
| Always, to Poe | 14 |
| Always, to Milton | 17 |
| Always, to bards | 16 |
| Always, to a verse writer | 25 |
| Always, romantically | 20 |
| Always, if the meter requires it | 32 |
| Always with an apostrophe | 25 |
| Always used by a poet | 21 |
| Always to poets | 16 |
| Always poetically | 18 |
| "What ___ thou art, act well thy part" | 48 |
| "Mountain" ending | 27 |
| "Lo, How a Rose ___ Blooming" (old hymn) | 50 |
| "Let not woman ___ complain": Burns | 45 |
| "If ___ he loved, 'twas her alone": Sir Walter Scott | 66 |
| "I love her ten times more than ___ I did": Petruchio | 63 |
| "I am worse than ___ I was": "King Lear" | 60 |
| "How ill to __ forget thee!": Whitman | 47 |
| "Black as --- was crow" | 33 |
| "Black as ___ was crow" | 33 |
| "As __ beneath a waning moon was haunted": Coleridge | 62 |
| "All that wealth ___ gave": Gray | 42 |
| "...all that wealth ___ gave": Gray | 45 |
| ''Mountain'' finish | 35 |
| Spooky | 6 |
| Weird | 5 |
| Peculiar | 8 |
| Uncanny | 7 |
| Creepy | 6 |
| Hair-raising | 12 |
| Like Poe's prose | 20 |
| Spine-chilling | 14 |
| Macabre | 7 |
| Like a haunted house | 20 |
| Unsettling | 10 |
| Frightening | 11 |
| Eldritch | 8 |
| Arcane | 6 |
| Willies-inducing | 16 |
| Like some coincidences | 22 |
| Very strange | 12 |
| Unnatural | 9 |
| Like freakish coincidences | 26 |
| Mysteriously spooky | 19 |
| Frightfully strange | 19 |
| A la King? | 10 |
| Weird in a creepy way | 21 |
| Ghastly strange | 15 |
| Bone-chilling | 13 |
| Haunting | 8 |
| Chill-inducing | 14 |
| Hitchcockian | 12 |
| Scary | 5 |
| Causing goose bumps | 19 |
| Supernatural | 12 |
| Freakish | 8 |
| Spectral | 8 |
| Ghoulish | 8 |
| Almost too coincidental | 23 |
| Weirder than weird | 18 |
| Preternatural | 13 |
| Like haunted houses | 19 |
| Like "The X-Files" | 28 |
| Goosebump-inducing | 18 |
| Chilling, in a way | 18 |
| Unworldly | 9 |
| Unsettlingly strange | 20 |
| Like a Stephen King story | 25 |
| Like a Poe tale | 15 |
| Like "The Twilight Zone" | 34 |
| Kind of silence | 15 |
| Alien | 5 |
| Uncannily spooky | 16 |
| Paranormal | 10 |
| More than odd | 13 |
| Like ghost stories | 18 |
| Like a Stephen King novel | 25 |
| Hard to explain | 15 |
| Goosebump-raising | 17 |
| Causing goosebumps | 18 |