| Birthday secret | 15 |
| It's often made with the eyes closed | 40 |
| Genie's bestowal | 20 |
| Genie offering | 14 |
| You may close your eyes when making it | 38 |
| You may break a bone after making it | 36 |
| Thought's father | 20 |
| Something made on a star? | 25 |
| It's made before blowing | 28 |
| It's made at a birthday party | 33 |
| It precedes a blowout? | 22 |
| Genie's grant | 17 |
| Genie's gift | 16 |
| Genie offer | 11 |
| Fond longing | 12 |
| Fond desire | 11 |
| Candle-blower's secret | 26 |
| Birthday-party tradition | 24 |
| "When You ___ Upon a Star" | 36 |
| "Peace on earth," e.g. | 32 |
| Words after a splash in a fountain, maybe | 41 |
| What a genie might grant | 24 |
| Well-spoken request? | 20 |
| Well product? | 13 |
| Well offering | 13 |
| Use a certain well | 18 |
| Thought's "father" | 32 |
| Thought before blowing out the candles | 38 |
| Specific longing | 16 |
| Something made before blowing out candles | 41 |
| Reward for a Trevi coin | 23 |
| Prepare to break a bone? | 24 |
| One may be made after blowing out candles | 41 |
| One may accompany a coin toss | 29 |
| Jinni's gift | 16 |
| Item on a list, perhaps | 23 |
| It's made as candles go out | 31 |
| It may be made by a stargazer | 29 |
| Hypothetical horse | 18 |
| Hope (for) | 10 |
| Fountain-coin product | 21 |
| Fountain request? | 17 |
| Fingers-crossed thought | 23 |
| Father to the thought | 21 |
| Fairy godmother's offering | 30 |
| Expression of desire | 20 |
| Candleblower's thought | 26 |
| Candle blower's secret | 26 |
| Bone or list preceder | 21 |
| Birthday thought | 16 |
| Birthday party tradition | 24 |
| Birthday creation | 17 |
| Becoming a real boy, for Pinocchio | 34 |
| Action before blowing out the candles | 37 |
| A stargazer may make one | 24 |
| A kind of bone | 14 |
| "You ___!" ("Yeah, right!") | 47 |
| "Father to the thought" | 33 |
| "___ you were here!" | 30 |
| Thanksgiving prize | 18 |
| Thanksgiving fork? | 18 |
| Source of a lucky break? | 24 |
| Relative of a drumstick | 23 |
| Offensive formation | 19 |
| Lucky break provider? | 21 |
| It could provide a lucky break? | 31 |
| Football backfield formation named for its shape | 48 |
| Turkey parts | 12 |
| One who mends desires? | 22 |
| Used a certain well | 19 |
| Acted after a coin toss, maybe | 30 |
| Well-___, as at a wedding | 25 |
| They may be made after coin tosses | 34 |
| They come in threes, often | 26 |
| Gifts from a genie | 18 |
| Well-made requests? | 19 |
| Trio granted by a genie | 23 |
| Trio from a genie | 17 |
| They often come in threes | 25 |
| Storied genie's trio | 24 |
| Offers from a genie | 19 |
| Horses in an iffy proverb | 25 |
| Fountain requests | 17 |
| Correspondent's word after "best" | 47 |
| Candle blowers' secrets | 27 |
| Birthday secrets | 16 |
| Beggars' horses | 19 |
| "If ___ were horses . . . " | 37 |
| Hope to get | 11 |
| Type of thinking | 16 |
| Autobiographical book by Carrie Fisher | 38 |
| Pair of cards with unreasonable aspirations? | 44 |
| Unrealistic expectation | 23 |
| Body english, in a way | 22 |
| Fairy godmother, e.g. | 21 |
| Words with may or might | 23 |
| Words that go in either blank of "___ may ___ might" | 62 |
| Words often heard before may and might | 38 |
| Words before may or might, in verse | 35 |
| Words before may or might | 25 |