| Three Wise Men | 14 |
| O. Henry's gift givers | 26 |
| Melchior et al. | 15 |
| Gospel's gift givers | 24 |
| Gift-bearing trio | 17 |
| Epiphany figures | 16 |
| Balthazar's group | 21 |
| Adoring trio | 12 |
| Adoring Biblical trio | 21 |
| ''The Gift of the ___'' | 39 |
| Wise threesome in Matthew | 25 |
| Wise men in a stable | 20 |
| Trio of wise visitors | 21 |
| Trio in Bethlehem | 17 |
| Three gift bearers | 18 |
| They followed that star | 23 |
| The kings of "We Three Kings" | 39 |
| Starstruck trio? | 16 |
| Star trekkers? | 14 |
| Star followers of note | 22 |
| O. Henry's "The Gift of the __" | 45 |
| Nativity-scene figures | 22 |
| Manger trio | 11 |
| Gift-giving trio | 16 |
| Famous gift givers | 18 |
| Early visitors to Jesus | 23 |
| Bethlehem trio | 14 |
| Bearers of gold, frankincense and myrrh | 39 |
| Ancient gift givers | 19 |
| Wise threesome | 14 |
| Wise men of the New Testament | 29 |
| Visitors to Jesus | 17 |
| Trio visiting Jesus | 19 |
| Trio in a Bible story | 21 |
| Trio bearing gifts | 18 |
| Traveling trio | 14 |
| Three associated with Christmas | 31 |
| They made a star trek | 21 |
| Subjects of a T. S. Eliot poem | 30 |
| Star seekers | 12 |
| O. Henry title word | 19 |
| O. Henry gift-givers | 20 |
| Noted wise guys | 15 |
| Noted star followers | 20 |
| Noted gift givers | 17 |
| Noted Christmas visitors | 24 |
| Noel trio | 9 |
| Nativity scene figures | 22 |
| Gift-givers, in an O. Henry story | 33 |
| Gift-bearing kings | 18 |
| Gaspar et al. | 13 |
| Epiphany honorees | 17 |
| Creche trio (with "the") | 34 |
| Christmas travelers | 19 |
| Christmas kings | 15 |
| Certain wise men | 16 |
| Caspar, Melchior and Balthazar | 30 |
| Carol kings | 11 |
| Biblical wise trio | 18 |
| Biblical wise guys | 18 |
| Balthazar et al. | 16 |
| Balthasar, Gaspar and Melchior | 30 |
| Amahl's visitors | 20 |
| Amahl's night visitors | 26 |
| Yuletide wise trio | 18 |
| Yuletide wise men | 17 |
| Yuletide guests | 15 |
| Yule threesome | 14 |
| Xmas-pageant figures | 20 |
| Word in an O. Henry title | 25 |
| Wise trio in Bethlehem | 22 |
| Wise men from the East | 22 |
| Wise guys featured in this puzzle's theme answers | 53 |
| Visitors to the manger | 22 |
| Visitors to infant Jesus | 24 |
| Visitors of Jesus | 17 |
| Trio on camels | 14 |
| Trio of gift-givers | 19 |
| Trio in a Christmas story | 25 |
| Trio from the East | 18 |
| Trio from Matthew | 17 |
| Trio following a star | 21 |
| Travellers from the East | 24 |
| Travelers of Biblical fame | 26 |
| Travelers in Matthew 2 | 22 |
| Travelers in Matthew | 20 |
| They saw the Light | 18 |
| They navigated by a star | 24 |
| They made a star trek? | 22 |
| They brought myrrh and more | 27 |
| The Three Kings | 15 |
| Starmen? | 8 |
| Star-trekkers of old | 20 |
| Star-struck trio? | 17 |
| Star-following trio | 19 |
| Star witnesses of old | 21 |
| Star trek voyagers? | 19 |
| Star of Bethlehem followers | 27 |
| Star men? | 9 |
| Stable group? | 13 |