| First name in misanthropy | 25 |
| First name in grinchiness | 25 |
| First name associated with Christmas, from the Hebrew for "rock of help" | 82 |
| Charles's miser | 19 |
| Brewer of Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase & Fable | 55 |
| Ray who sang with the Glenn Miller Orchestra | 44 |
| Glenn Miller protégé Ray | 30 |
| Big Band singer Ray | 19 |
| U. S. sculptor | 14 |
| Singer/bandleader Ray | 21 |
| Singer Ray with the Glenn Miller Orchestra | 42 |
| Singer Ray of the big band era | 30 |
| Glenn Miller vocalist | 21 |
| Glenn Miller Band vocalist Ray | 30 |
| 40's singing brother Ray or Bob | 35 |
| "Over the Rainbow" vocalist Ray | 41 |
| Movie critic Roger | 18 |
| Film critic Roger | 17 |
| "I Hated, Hated, Hated This Movie" author | 51 |
| Critic Roger | 12 |
| Reviewer Roger | 14 |
| Siskel's partner | 20 |
| Roeper's partner | 20 |
| Film reviewer Roger | 19 |
| 1975 Pulitzer winner for criticism | 34 |
| Man with memorable thumbs | 25 |
| First German president | 22 |
| Weimar Republic's first president | 37 |
| Noted film reviewer | 19 |
| German president | 16 |
| First president of Germany | 26 |
| Chicago-based film critic | 25 |
| 1975 Pulitzer-winning critic | 28 |
| "Your Movie Sucks" writer | 35 |
| "Your Movie Sucks" author | 35 |
| "Questions for the Movie Answer Man" author | 53 |
| "Awake in the Dark" author | 36 |
| Thumbs-up reviewer | 18 |
| Siskel's TV partner | 23 |
| Siskel's cohort | 19 |
| Roger who left "At the Movies" | 40 |
| Roger of film criticism | 23 |
| Noted reviewer | 14 |
| Movie reviewer Roger | 20 |
| Man with a powerful thumb | 25 |
| Man with a notable thumb | 24 |
| Man with a famous thumb | 23 |
| Hindenburg's predecessor as German president | 48 |
| Guy who was all thumbs? | 23 |
| Guest commenter Roger on the 70th Anniversary DVD edition of "Casablanca" | 83 |
| German statesman | 16 |
| Forbes' "most powerful pundit" | 44 |
| First president of the German republic, 1919 | 44 |
| First film critic to win a Pulitzer | 35 |
| Film maven Roger | 16 |
| Film critic from Chicago | 24 |
| Film buff Roger | 15 |
| Critic with a Hollywood Walk of Fame star | 41 |
| Chicago reviewer | 16 |
| Chicago film reviewer | 21 |
| Chicago film critic | 19 |
| Big name in criticism | 21 |
| "The Great Movies" author | 35 |
| ''At the Movies'' name | 38 |
| Writer who's always seeing things? | 38 |
| Who said "No good movie is too long, and no bad movie is short enough" | 80 |
| Viewer of many a film | 21 |
| TV movie critic of note | 23 |
| Thumbs-up/thumbs-down guy | 25 |
| Thumbs-up critic | 16 |
| Thumbs up/thumbs down critic | 28 |
| Thumb-raising film critic | 25 |
| Thumb-raising critic | 20 |
| Subject of the 2014 documentary "Life Itself" | 55 |
| Siskel's sidekick | 21 |
| Roger with an influential thumb | 31 |
| Roger with a thumbs-up or thumbs-down | 37 |
| Roger with a respected thumb | 28 |
| Roger with a powerful thumb | 27 |
| Roger the reviewer | 18 |
| Roger of the balcony | 20 |
| Roger of reviews | 16 |
| Roger at the movies | 19 |
| Roeper's TV partner | 23 |
| Rival of Maltin | 15 |
| Reviewer from Chicago | 21 |
| Pulitzer-winning reviewer | 25 |
| Pulitzer-winning film critic Roger | 34 |
| President succeeded by Hindenburg | 33 |
| Partner of Roeper | 17 |
| Owner of a famous thumb | 23 |
| Onetime partner of Siskel | 25 |
| Oft-quoted critic | 17 |
| Noted Chicago Sun-Times critic | 30 |
| Movie maker ... or breaker? | 27 |
| Movie hater, at times | 21 |
| Movie critic Siskel's TV partner | 36 |
| Man with a respected thumb | 26 |
| Man with a noted thumb | 22 |
| Man with a mighty thumb | 23 |