| Requiring many candles on a birthday cake | 41 |
| Part of VSOP | 12 |
| Outmoded, e.g. | 14 |
| Mossy | 5 |
| Medieval, e.g. | 14 |
| Maid or master | 14 |
| Long established | 16 |
| Like the man in a Hemingway title | 33 |
| Like the hills? | 15 |
| Like the hills | 14 |
| Like the gray mare of song | 26 |
| Like the gray mare | 18 |
| Like the Curiosity Shop | 23 |
| Like King Cole | 14 |
| Like Joe Miller jokes | 21 |
| Like Glory | 10 |
| Like a joke told far too often | 30 |
| Having had many birthdays | 25 |
| Hardly original | 15 |
| Going way back, as friends | 26 |
| Glory or hat | 12 |
| Geezerish | 9 |
| From ancient times | 18 |
| Familiar, as friends | 20 |
| Faithful or reliable word | 25 |
| Collectible, maybe | 18 |
| Chronic | 7 |
| "Something ___ . . . " | 32 |
| "No Country for ___ Men" | 34 |
| "I hope I die before I get ___" | 41 |
| "... at the ___ ball game!" | 37 |
| "--- Fashioned Love Song" | 35 |
| ___ Vic | 7 |
| Word with school or guard | 25 |
| Word with man or woman | 22 |
| Word with hat or timers | 23 |
| Word with hat or time | 21 |
| Word with Harry or Nick | 23 |
| Word with guard or gate | 23 |
| Word with gold or rose | 22 |
| Word with Glory | 15 |
| Word with "Spice" in a brand name | 43 |
| Word with ''chap'' or ''fellow'' | 64 |
| Word replaced in three answers in this puzzle | 45 |
| Word before school or master | 28 |
| Word before Glory or Testament | 30 |
| Word before country or school | 29 |
| What The Who didn't want to get | 35 |
| What few want to grow | 21 |
| What Father William was | 23 |
| Wharton's "The ___ Maid" | 38 |
| Up there, say | 13 |
| Unlike spring chickens | 22 |
| The kind of friends that go way back | 36 |
| The "O" in G.O.P. | 27 |
| Stale, say | 10 |
| Stale, perhaps | 14 |
| Singer's "___ Love": 1979 | 39 |
| Senile | 6 |
| Resembling King Cole | 20 |
| Requiring many candles | 22 |
| Pulitzer winner, "The ___ Maid": 1935 | 47 |
| Primeval | 8 |
| Previously superseded | 21 |
| Previously heard | 16 |
| Pre-Columbian | 13 |
| Picasso's "The ___ Guitarist" | 43 |
| Past maturity | 13 |
| Part of O.T. | 12 |
| One of the Testaments | 21 |
| Oaken bucket or gray mare | 25 |
| O.T. part | 9 |
| Not cutting-edge | 16 |
| Noachian | 8 |
| No longer funny | 15 |
| No longer amusing | 17 |
| Neil Young: "___ Man" | 31 |
| Much-used | 9 |
| Moth-eaten, maybe | 17 |
| Methuselah-like | 15 |
| Master or maid | 14 |
| Maid or hat | 11 |
| Long-established | 16 |
| Long in tooth | 13 |
| Long familiar | 13 |
| Like Vic or Bailey | 18 |
| Like very familiar jokes | 24 |
| Like the oaken bucket | 21 |
| Like the food in the back of the fridge, maybe | 46 |
| Like tall redwoods | 18 |
| Like stuff in the attic, often | 30 |
| Like stale jokes | 16 |
| Like retreads | 13 |
| Like Picasso's guitarist | 28 |
| Like Nick or Harry | 18 |
| Like most codgers | 17 |
| Like most carbon-dating specimens | 33 |
| Like most carbon dating specimens | 33 |
| Like Millvina Dean, the last living survivor from the Titanic | 61 |
| Like MacDonald or Glory | 23 |