| Misgiving | 9 |
| Reservation | 11 |
| Misgivings | 10 |
| Meryl Streep movie | 18 |
| Have reservations about | 23 |
| Have reservations | 17 |
| Feeling of uncertainty | 22 |
| Emulate Thomas | 14 |
| Skepticism | 10 |
| Question the truth of | 21 |
| Philip Seymour Hoffman film of 2008 | 35 |
| It may be reasonable | 20 |
| It may be lingering | 19 |
| Feel uncertain about | 20 |
| Distrust | 8 |
| Be skeptical | 12 |
| Without a ____ | 14 |
| Thomas's problem | 20 |
| Skeptic's forte | 19 |
| Shadow of a ___ | 15 |
| Reason for hesitating | 21 |
| Mistrust | 8 |
| Lack of conviction | 18 |
| Its shadow is often cast | 24 |
| It may be raised or cast | 24 |
| Have questions about | 20 |
| Harbor suspicions | 17 |
| Find fishy | 10 |
| Don't buy | 13 |
| Cornerstone of Cartesianism | 27 |
| Consider unlikely | 17 |
| Cold feet, essentially | 22 |
| Act the skeptic | 15 |
| Act like the Apostle Thomas | 27 |
| "When in ___ tell the truth": Twain | 45 |
| "No ___!" ("Of course!") | 44 |
| "I ___ it" | 20 |
| Wasn't sure | 15 |
| Had qualms | 10 |
| Was uncertain of | 16 |
| Had reservations | 16 |
| Considered questionable | 23 |
| Skeptic | 7 |
| Hard to believe | 15 |
| Suspicions | 10 |
| Second thoughts | 15 |
| Is a skeptic | 12 |
| True believers don't have them | 34 |
| They may be reasonable | 22 |
| Loses the faith? | 16 |
| Is skeptical about | 18 |
| Holds questionable | 18 |
| Has reservations | 16 |
| Emulates a notable Thomas | 25 |
| Emulates a biblical Thomas | 26 |
| "Irma la ___" | 23 |
| 'Irma la --' | 20 |
| Sweet, in a Shirley MacLaine film | 33 |
| Magician Henning | 16 |
| Quarterback Flutie | 18 |
| "The King of Queens" first name | 41 |
| QB Flutie | 9 |
| Henning or Flutie | 17 |
| Nickelodeon character Funnie | 28 |
| Magic man Henning | 17 |
| Late magician Henning | 21 |
| Illusionist Henning | 19 |
| Henning or McClure | 18 |
| Henning of magic | 16 |
| General MacArthur, to friends | 29 |
| Former QB Flutie | 16 |
| Former NFL quarterback Flutie | 29 |
| Fairbanks, to friends | 21 |
| Baseball's Drabek | 21 |
| "The Bourne Identity" director Liman | 46 |
| ''The King of Queens'' character | 48 |
| Writer Woolf, to friends | 24 |
| Super Bowl XXII MVP Williams | 28 |
| Sixth-grader of a 1990s cartoon series | 38 |
| QB Flutie or Williams | 21 |
| Pulitzer-winning editorial cartoonist Marlette | 46 |
| Paris Hilton's on again/off again boyfriend Rienhardt | 57 |
| Nickelodeon toon whose last name is Funnie | 42 |
| Nickelodeon cartoon star | 24 |
| Heisman winner Flutie | 21 |
| Former quarterback Flutie | 25 |
| Flutie of football | 18 |
| First baseman Mientkiewicz who caught the final out of the 2004 Boston World Series victory | 91 |
| Fairbanks | 9 |
| Ex-QB Flutie | 12 |
| Davidson of "Y&R" | 31 |
| Cy Young-winning pitcher Drabek | 31 |
| Built to Spill singer Martsch | 29 |
| Bob McKenzie's "Great White North" brother | 56 |
| Animated show on Nickelodeon | 28 |
| 1990s Nickelodeon series | 24 |
| 1990 N.L. Cy Young Award winner Drabek | 38 |
| ''The King of Queens'' first name | 49 |
| Bankroll | 8 |
| Dinero | 6 |