| Played for a cat's-paw | 26 |
| Owned previously | 16 |
| Owned by another at one time | 28 |
| Outside the box? | 16 |
| Not worth as much, probably | 27 |
| Not pristine | 12 |
| Not new or mint | 15 |
| Not factory-fresh | 17 |
| New's opposite | 18 |
| New no more | 11 |
| Marked down, most likely | 24 |
| Made the most of | 16 |
| Made a pawn of | 14 |
| Listed on eBay, often | 21 |
| Like vintage clothes, usually | 29 |
| Like trade-ins | 14 |
| Like thrift-store wares | 23 |
| Like thrift-shop wares | 22 |
| Like thrift-shop merchandise | 28 |
| Like thrift-shop goods | 22 |
| Like thrift store merchandise | 29 |
| Like thrift shop wares | 22 |
| Like taped baseballs | 20 |
| Like some low-cost merchandise | 30 |
| Like some lot offerings | 23 |
| Like some eBay goods | 20 |
| Like some campus bookstore offerings | 36 |
| Like some books or records | 26 |
| Like some books or cars | 23 |
| Like some books and cars | 24 |
| Like some boats, when bought | 28 |
| Like some automobiles | 21 |
| Like most yard sale goods | 25 |
| Like most resale-rack items | 27 |
| Like most garage sale items | 27 |
| Like most consignment shop items | 32 |
| Like many textbooks | 19 |
| Like many items listed on eBay | 30 |
| Like many flea market items | 27 |
| Like many eBay offerings | 24 |
| Like many college texts | 23 |
| Like many a car | 15 |
| Like flea market items | 22 |
| Like cars in many classifieds | 29 |
| Like antiques | 13 |
| Like almost all antiques | 24 |
| Like a thrift store item | 24 |
| Like a car with 20,000 miles on its odometer | 44 |
| Kind of car on a certain lot | 28 |
| Inured (to) | 11 |
| How textbooks may be sold | 25 |
| How saps might feel | 19 |
| Having some mileage on it | 25 |
| Hand-me-down Utah band, with "The"? | 45 |
| Got mileage out of | 18 |
| From the Salvation Army, say | 28 |
| Far from factory-fresh | 22 |
| Didn't leave on the shelf | 29 |
| Cheaper, usually | 16 |
| Canceled, as a stamp | 20 |
| Bought before | 13 |
| Bought at a garage sale | 23 |
| Adhibited | 9 |
| Adapted (to) | 12 |
| Abused partner? | 15 |
| "You ___ to come at ten o'clock" | 46 |
| "Previously loved" | 28 |
| "New to you," in car salesman-speak | 45 |
| "I ___ to love her, but I had to kill her" | 52 |
| "All That I've Got" Utah band, with "The" | 65 |
| "___ to Love Her" | 27 |
| "___ People," MacLaine film | 37 |
| "___ Cars," 1980 film | 31 |
| 'Get -- to it!' | 23 |
| ''Previously owned,'' in ad-speak | 49 |
| ___-car lot | 11 |
| ___ up (finished) | 17 |
| ___ up (expended) | 17 |
| ___ to be | 9 |
| ___ car dealer | 14 |
| ___ crib (cheated) | 18 |
| Child's offering for a swap | 31 |
| Celebrated Talk Like a Pirate Day? | 34 |
| Set of wheels with a history | 28 |
| Item on a lot | 13 |
| Vehicle that's been around the block | 40 |
| Sonata that might not sound good | 32 |
| Something with a Blue Book value | 32 |
| Something bought from a lot | 27 |
| Sight on a lot | 14 |
| Ride with history | 17 |
| Previously owned vehicle | 24 |
| Preowned wheels | 15 |
| One of a lot on a lot | 21 |
| Lemon, possibly | 15 |
| Kelley Blue Book listing | 24 |
| Item seen in lots of lots | 25 |
| It may be worth a little on a lot | 33 |
| Focus that might be a little off | 32 |
| Classified item, often | 22 |