| Tiny dog | 8 |
| Tinker with, with "with" | 34 |
| Stocking stuffer found in seven of this puzzle's longest answers | 68 |
| Spirograph, e.g. | 16 |
| Spice source, in bed | 20 |
| Soldier to play with | 20 |
| Slinky or Frisbee | 17 |
| Slinky or boomerang | 19 |
| Sled, e.g. | 10 |
| Shih-tzu, e.g. | 14 |
| Santa's offering | 20 |
| Ray gun, most likely | 20 |
| Racer from Santa, e.g. | 22 |
| Popgun, e.g. | 12 |
| Poodle, perhaps | 15 |
| Poodle, maybe | 13 |
| Playskool product | 17 |
| Play cat and mouse (with) | 25 |
| Play (with), as someone's heart | 35 |
| Petite pup | 10 |
| Pennywhistle or pinwheel | 24 |
| Part of Santa's bagful | 26 |
| Papillon, for example | 21 |
| North Pole product | 18 |
| Mr. Potato Head, for example | 28 |
| Model airplane, e.g. | 20 |
| Miniature dog | 13 |
| Mini-dog | 8 |
| Mattel specialty | 16 |
| Martika hit "--- Soldiers" | 36 |
| Many an item in Santa's bag | 31 |
| Many a Christmas present | 24 |
| Many a Christmas gift | 21 |
| Little Boy Blue's dog | 25 |
| Lite-Brite, for one | 19 |
| Lap dog, often | 14 |
| Kite, e.g. | 10 |
| Kindergarten item | 17 |
| Kind of dog or fish | 19 |
| Kind of "Soldier," to Britney | 39 |
| Kiddie litter bit | 17 |
| Kid's amuser | 16 |
| Kazoo, for one | 14 |
| Item on a Christmas list | 24 |
| Item in Santa's sack | 24 |
| Item in a playpen | 17 |
| It may come with a choking hazard warning | 41 |
| It may be wound up | 18 |
| Haydn's ___ Symphony | 24 |
| Happy Meal throw-in | 19 |
| Happy Meal extra | 16 |
| Goody from Santa's workshop | 31 |
| Gift under a tree, often | 24 |
| First car, for many? | 20 |
| First car, for many | 19 |
| FAO Schwarz product | 19 |
| FAO Schwartz product | 20 |
| Eminem "Like ___ Soldiers" | 36 |
| Easy-Bake Oven, e.g. | 20 |
| Dog size | 8 |
| Dog bred for smallness | 22 |
| Diminutive, as a dog | 20 |
| Deal lightly with | 17 |
| Deal lightly | 12 |
| Cracker Jack surprise | 21 |
| Cracker Jack feature | 20 |
| Cracker Jack box bonus | 22 |
| Consider briefly, with "with" | 39 |
| Common Christmas gift | 21 |
| Christmas wish list item | 24 |
| Christmas present, often | 24 |
| Christmas gift for a kid | 24 |
| Christmas catalog item | 22 |
| Child's amusement | 21 |
| Cereal-box freebie, often | 25 |
| Boy ___ (cougar's catch) | 28 |
| Bandalore, e.g. | 15 |
| Action figure, e.g. | 19 |
| 1995 animated movie ____ Story | 33 |
| 1982 Pryor film, with "The" | 37 |
| "The dog is not a ___!" | 33 |
| ''___ Story'' (1995) | 36 |
| '-- Story 3' | 20 |
| _____ with (tease) | 18 |
| ___ with (tease) | 16 |
| ___ poodle | 10 |
| __ poodle | 9 |
| Slaughter "Stick It ___" | 34 |
| One-named "I Do!" singer named for a Jackson | 54 |
| "What's it __?" | 29 |
| Petra "More Power ___" | 32 |
| Michael's sister La ___ | 27 |
| La ___ Jackson | 14 |
| Chantay Savage "Give It ___" | 38 |
| Teddy bear | 10 |
| Items in Santa's bag | 24 |
| Place for playthings | 20 |
| Tongue-twisting bathtub plaything | 33 |
| Tug in the tub, perhaps | 23 |
| Bathtime plaything that's also a tongue twister | 51 |