| Piece of pastry | 15 |
| Like Granny Smith apples | 24 |
| Causing one to pucker | 21 |
| Causing a pucker | 16 |
| Like crab apples | 16 |
| Like a sucker that makes you pucker | 35 |
| Like a Granny Smith apple | 25 |
| Pointed, in a way | 17 |
| Pielet | 6 |
| Pastry offering | 15 |
| Not bland | 9 |
| Needing sweetening | 18 |
| Loose lass | 10 |
| Like vinaigrette | 16 |
| Like lemonade | 13 |
| Like key lime pie | 17 |
| Like Granny Smiths | 18 |
| Lemony, e.g. | 12 |
| Fruit pie | 9 |
| Frangipane | 10 |
| Booty for the Knave of Hearts | 29 |
| What a frangipani might fill | 28 |
| Treat for Knave of Hearts | 25 |
| Tongue-curling | 14 |
| Tasting like unripe apples | 26 |
| Tasting like a lemon | 20 |
| Target of Jack of Hearts | 24 |
| Sour Elvis Costello song? | 25 |
| Small dessert | 13 |
| Shellful of jelly | 17 |
| Sharp to the taste | 18 |
| Sharp tasting | 13 |
| Repeated word in Happy Mondays song | 35 |
| Raspberry ___ | 13 |
| Queen of Hearts product | 23 |
| Queen of Hearts goody | 21 |
| Pumpkins lyric "Pop ___, what's our mission?" | 59 |
| Petite pie | 10 |
| Pastry treat | 12 |
| Pastry product | 14 |
| Part of a knave's loot, in a rhyme | 38 |
| Nick of Diamond Head | 20 |
| Minipie | 7 |
| Miniature pie | 13 |
| Little pastry | 13 |
| Likely to produce a pucker | 26 |
| Like tamarinds | 14 |
| Like sourballs | 14 |
| Like sour cherries | 18 |
| Like rhubarb | 12 |
| Like limeade | 12 |
| Like lemonade sans sugar | 24 |
| Like cooking apples | 19 |
| Like a sloe | 11 |
| Knave's sweet tooth item? | 29 |
| Key lime pie, or its taste | 26 |
| Jelly-filled pastry | 19 |
| Jam-filled pastry | 17 |
| Item made by a queen | 20 |
| Item filched by a knave | 23 |
| Ho, to a senior citizen | 23 |
| High tea goody | 14 |
| Elvis Costello song to pucker lips to? | 38 |
| Elvis Costello song about a pastry? | 35 |
| Dessert tray pick | 17 |
| Dessert offering | 16 |
| Dessert for one | 15 |
| Decorate gaudily, with "up" | 37 |
| Christmas pie | 13 |
| Cherry-filled dessert | 21 |
| Certain raspberry pastry | 24 |
| Causing puckers | 15 |
| Bit of pastry | 13 |
| Bimbo | 5 |
| Barbed, in a way | 16 |
| Barbed | 6 |
| Banbury treat | 13 |
| Bakery bite | 11 |
| Baker's sweet treat | 23 |
| Apple-filled pastry | 19 |
| Agreeably sharp | 15 |
| "Alice in Wonderland" pastry | 38 |
| A pastry in Peru | 16 |
| Plaid | 5 |
| Clan cloth | 10 |
| Clan pattern | 12 |
| Plaid pattern | 13 |
| Kilt makeup | 11 |
| Kilt fabric | 11 |
| Highlander's pattern | 24 |
| Scottish plaid | 14 |
| Scottish fabric | 15 |
| Plaid cloth | 11 |
| Kiltie's pattern | 20 |
| Kilt material | 13 |
| Clan's pride | 16 |
| Clan's emblem | 17 |
| Striped identifier | 18 |
| Scotch plaid | 12 |
| Plaid or ship | 13 |