| American atheist leader | 23 |
| 2011 Canadian Open champ Sean | 29 |
| Atheist Madalyn et al. | 22 |
| Unlikely Broadway production about the life of an atheist? | 58 |
| Shakespeare on overthrowing first ("Julius Caesar," V, iii, 6) | 72 |
| On a miscue: "Julius Caesar" | 38 |
| Passionate utterance | 20 |
| "Chantilly Lace" exclamation | 38 |
| '90s-'00s Lifetime sitcom in which viewers chose the name of the title character | 88 |
| Woeful words from Winnie the Pooh | 33 |
| Winnie-the-Pooh catchphrase | 27 |
| "Such a headache!" | 28 |
| "How frustrating!" | 28 |
| Stephen Foster tune, "___ Carry Me 'Long" | 55 |
| Musical featuring "I Like the Look" | 45 |
| Broadway musical with two exclamation points in its name | 56 |
| Broadway hit: 1969 | 18 |
| 1959 Neil Sedaka hit | 20 |
| Top 10 hit for Neil Sedaka | 26 |
| Neil Sedaka hit | 15 |
| Neil Sedaka's first Top Ten hit | 35 |
| Neil Sedaka hit of 1959 | 23 |
| Line from ". . . All Ye Faithful" | 43 |
| "Let's be serious here ..." | 41 |
| "Seriously?!?" | 24 |
| "You have got to be kidding!" | 39 |
| Mossy growth on a pterodactyl's wattlebone | 46 |
| "I was hoping that wouldn't happen" | 49 |
| Start of a popular Irish ballad | 31 |
| "Gee, wouldn't that just figure..." | 49 |
| "...___ is mine and I am his..." | 42 |
| Expressed surprise | 18 |
| Was audibly surprised, maybe | 28 |
| Expressed some surprise | 23 |
| Zerubbabel's son | 20 |
| Hawaiian blueberry | 18 |
| Stories by a U. S. writer | 25 |
| Distant descendant of author William Sydney Porter? | 51 |
| NFL star Michael who was the basis for the movie "The Blind Side" | 75 |
| Character actor Dan | 19 |
| Shak. play whose original title was "Hey, You"? | 57 |
| Resigned utterance | 18 |
| #1 hit for the Chi-Lites, 1972 | 30 |
| George Burns sequel: 1980 | 25 |
| 1984 George Burns sequel | 24 |
| 1984 George Burns comedy | 24 |
| "That's terrific" | 31 |
| "Now what's wrong!" | 33 |
| "I finally get it!" | 29 |
| Stomachachy moan | 16 |
| Cry from one who just got the joke | 34 |
| Gospel standard based on an 18th-century hymn | 45 |
| Expression akin to "shucks" | 37 |
| "Darn it," a little more strongly | 43 |
| Card game beloved by Howard Dean | 32 |
| Sweet treat with an exclamation point in its name | 49 |
| "Oops, almost forgot ..." | 35 |
| "___ I Hate to Get Up . . . " | 39 |
| Breakfaster's sad comment? | 30 |
| Hawaiian fruit tree | 19 |
| Hawaiian fruit | 14 |
| "Well, it sure beats me" | 34 |
| "Not necessarily" | 27 |
| "Hmm, ya got me" | 26 |
| "Hmm ... lemme think" | 31 |
| 'Not necessarily' | 25 |
| "___ I had the wings . . . " | 38 |
| Slow-on-the-uptake response | 27 |
| Ashtabula tree | 14 |
| Route of some Lake Erie ferries? | 32 |
| Southern border of the Northwest Territory | 42 |
| Kentucky's northern border | 30 |
| It's just west of Wheeling | 30 |
| It ends at Cairo | 16 |
| Belle of Louisville's beat | 30 |
| Brutus Buckeye's school | 27 |
| Where Woody Hayes coached | 25 |
| School whose football stadium is nicknamed the Horseshoe | 56 |
| RL Stine alma mater | 19 |
| It has the world's largest brass band | 41 |
| Columbus's flagship? | 24 |
| Columbus school | 15 |
| Its eastern end passes south of Youngstown | 42 |
| I-80 in part | 13 |
| Wheeling, Cincinnati and Louisville are in it | 45 |
| Prime Minister before Suzuki | 28 |
| Japanese P.M.: 1978-80 | 22 |
| Former Tokyo V.I.P. | 19 |
| Facetious "Great!" | 28 |
| Catchphrase for Stimpy | 22 |
| "That's great ... not!" | 37 |
| Gershwins musical of 1926-27 | 28 |
| Gershwin musical: 1926 | 22 |
| Town in W. Va. | 14 |
| Swedish Nobelist in Economics | 29 |
| The low (really low) self-esteem song? | 38 |
| "You have to see this" | 32 |
| "You have to see this!" | 33 |
| "Hey, check that out!" | 32 |
| Excited pointer's comment | 29 |