| Hall of Fame pro wrestler known for wearing a kilt | 50 |
| Hall of Fame pop group The Four __, and last of this puzzle theme's five anagrams | 85 |
| Hall of Fame pool player __ Mataya Laurance | 43 |
| Hall of Fame placekicker Groza | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitchers Bunning and Palmer | 40 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher-citrus grower? | 35 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher ___ Wynn | 29 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Wilhelm | 28 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Warren | 27 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Waite __ | 29 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Spahn | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher since '97 | 34 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Seaver's nickname | 42 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Ryan | 25 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Red | 24 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Perry | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Lyons | 26 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher known as "Bullet Bob" | 52 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Eckersley | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Coveleski | 30 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Blyleven | 29 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher Amos | 25 |
| Hall of Fame pitcher | 20 |
| Hall of Fame outfielder Roush | 29 |
| Hall of Fame outfielder Earl __ | 31 |
| Hall of Fame outfielder Dave or actor Paul | 42 |
| Hall of Fame NFL owner Wellington __ | 36 |
| Hall of Fame NFL coach Ewbank | 29 |
| Hall of Fame NFL coach Chuck | 28 |
| Hall of Fame name | 17 |
| Hall of Fame members | 20 |
| Hall of Fame manager Weaver | 27 |
| Hall of Fame manager Tommy | 26 |
| Hall of Fame manager of the New York Giants nicknamed "Little Napoleon" | 81 |
| Hall of Fame manager Durocher | 29 |
| Hall of Fame manager Anderson | 29 |
| Hall of Fame manager | 20 |
| Hall of Fame lefty with 363 wins | 32 |
| Hall of Fame Lakers announcer | 29 |
| Hall of Fame knuckleballer Wilhelm | 34 |
| Hall of Fame jockey Sloan | 25 |
| Hall of Fame jockey Ron | 23 |
| Hall of Fame jockey Eddie | 25 |
| Hall of Fame jockey Earl | 24 |
| Hall of Fame infielder Roberto | 30 |
| Hall of Fame infielder | 22 |
| Hall of fame in music | 21 |
| Hall of Fame hurler | 19 |
| Hall of Fame hoopster Patrick | 29 |
| Hall of Fame hockey coach Roger | 31 |
| Hall of Fame hanging | 20 |
| Hall of Fame guest of honor | 27 |
| Hall of Fame golfer who invented the all-plastic club? | 54 |
| Hall of Fame golfer Middlecoff who had a DDS degree | 51 |
| Hall of Fame golfer | 19 |
| Hall of Fame goalie Patrick __ | 30 |
| Hall of Fame goalie Jacques | 27 |
| Hall of Fame goalie | 19 |
| Hall of Fame fullback Larry | 27 |
| Hall of Fame football player nicknamed "The Grand Old Man" who played for a record 26 seasons | 103 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Tom | 31 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Joe | 31 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Hank | 32 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Greasy | 34 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Ewbank | 34 |
| Hall of Fame football coach Earle "Greasy" __ | 55 |
| Hall of Fame football coach | 27 |
| Hall of Fame first baseman Johnny | 33 |
| Hall of Fame educator ___ Willard | 33 |
| Hall of Fame Dodgers shortstop | 30 |
| Hall of Fame Dodger pitcher | 27 |
| Hall of Fame Dodger | 19 |
| Hall of Fame DJ who popularized the term "rock-and-roll" | 66 |
| Hall of Fame defensive end Marchetti | 36 |
| Hall of Fame defensive back Mel | 31 |
| Hall of Fame defenseman Bobby | 29 |
| Hall of Fame coach Hank of Oklahoma State | 41 |
| Hall of Fame coach Ewbank | 25 |
| Hall of Fame Chargers quarterback Dan | 37 |
| Hall of Fame center fielder Richie | 34 |
| Hall of Fame center fielder Joe | 31 |
| Hall of Fame Celtic whose initials are his given name | 53 |
| Hall of Fame catcher Lombardi | 29 |
| Hall of Fame catcher Carlton | 28 |
| Hall of Fame catcher | 20 |
| Hall of Fame cager Patrick | 26 |
| Hall of Fame Broncos quarterback | 32 |
| Hall of Fame boxer | 18 |
| Hall of Fame bowler Dick or Pete | 32 |
| Hall of Fame botanist, ___ Gray | 31 |
| Hall of Fame botanist ___ Gray | 30 |
| Hall of Fame BoSox outfielder | 29 |
| Hall of Fame BoSox favorite, familiarly | 39 |
| Hall of Fame basketball coach Pat | 33 |
| Hall of Fame baseman George | 27 |
| Hall of Fame baseballer Al all wet? | 35 |
| Hall of Fame baseball manager Connie | 36 |
| Hall of Fame ballplayer Slaughter | 33 |
| Hall of Fame '40s-'50s Browns quarterback | 49 |
| Hall of fame | 12 |