| Like shellfish | 14 |
| Like shells | 11 |
| Like shelves pre-Black Friday | 29 |
| Like shepherd's pie | 23 |
| Like sherbets | 13 |
| Like Sherlock Holmes | 20 |
| Like Sherlock Holmes' game? | 31 |
| Like Sherlock Holmes's nose | 31 |
| Like Sherlock Holmes's powers | 33 |
| Like Sherlock Holmes, sometimes | 31 |
| Like Sherlock's methods | 27 |
| Like Sherman Klump | 18 |
| Like sherpas | 12 |
| Like Sheryl Swoopes, since October 2005 | 39 |
| Like Shih Tzus | 14 |
| Like shiny floors | 17 |
| Like shipping and handling, typically: Abbr. | 44 |
| Like Shirley Temple's hair | 30 |
| Like Shirley Temple's hairdo | 32 |
| Like shirts with the tag showing, sometimes | 43 |
| Like shish kebab | 16 |
| Like shock rocker | 17 |
| Like shoe polish | 16 |
| Like shoe-thrower Muntader Al-Zaidi | 35 |
| Like shoes | 10 |
| Like shoes and socks | 20 |
| Like shoes made in St. Louis and finished in New Orleans? | 57 |
| Like shoot-em-up films | 22 |
| Like shopping done all in the same place | 40 |
| Like shopping in megamarts | 26 |
| Like shorelines, often | 22 |
| Like short dicts. | 17 |
| Like shortstops before Ripken | 29 |
| Like Shostakovich's Symphony No. 2 | 38 |
| Like show horses | 16 |
| Like show horses' feet | 26 |
| Like shower rooms, often | 24 |
| Like shower stalls, typically | 29 |
| Like shower walls | 17 |
| Like shows many miles away | 26 |
| Like Shrek | 10 |
| Like Shrek (Var.) | 17 |
| Like shrimp during shipping | 27 |
| Like Shriners or Templars | 25 |
| Like Shriners' hats | 23 |
| Like shrinking violets | 22 |
| Like Shylock | 12 |
| Like Sibelius' valse | 24 |
| Like Siberia in January | 23 |
| Like Siberian winters | 21 |
| Like Siberian winters, compared to ours | 39 |
| Like siblings | 13 |
| Like sides of pyramids | 22 |
| Like sidewalk dining | 20 |
| Like Sidney Lumet's 12 men | 30 |
| Like Sidney Lumet's men | 27 |
| Like Sidney Lumet's twelve men | 34 |
| Like Sienna marble | 18 |
| Like sign in concert hall | 25 |
| Like signs | 10 |
| Like Silas Marner | 17 |
| Like Silas Marner before finding Eppie | 38 |
| Like silhouettes | 16 |
| Like silhouettes, typically | 27 |
| Like Silk Cut cigarettes | 24 |
| Like silly fools or maple trees | 31 |
| Like Silly Putty | 16 |
| Like silver and gold | 20 |
| Like Silver's rider | 23 |
| Like silverware, e.g. | 21 |
| Like Simba | 10 |
| Like Simba or Nala | 18 |
| Like Simba, but not Nala | 24 |
| Like Simeon Stylites | 20 |
| Like Simon | 10 |
| Like Simon Legree | 17 |
| Like Simon's ''Couple'' | 43 |
| Like Simon's couple | 23 |
| Like Simone Martini's art | 29 |
| Like simple instructions | 24 |
| Like Simple Simon? | 18 |
| Like simple survey questions | 28 |
| Like simple-to-answer questions | 31 |
| Like Sinatra | 12 |
| Like Sinatra playing Caruso? | 28 |
| Like sine waves | 15 |
| Like Singha beer | 16 |
| Like singing | 12 |
| Like singing in a shower | 24 |
| Like single-digit temps | 23 |
| Like single-malt scotch | 23 |
| Like single-malt whiskey | 24 |
| Like single-purpose committees | 30 |
| Like singles | 12 |
| Like sinners, to preachers | 26 |
| Like Sir Ian McKellen | 21 |
| Like sirens | 11 |
| Like sissies? | 13 |
| Like sisters | 12 |
| Like six of one and half a dozen of another | 43 |