| Pirate riches | 13 |
| Pirate realm | 12 |
| Pirate quaffs | 13 |
| Pirate quaff | 12 |
| Pirate punishment | 17 |
| Pirate potables | 15 |
| Pirate potable | 14 |
| Pirate portrayer of film | 24 |
| Pirate portrayer | 16 |
| Pirate player Johnny | 20 |
| Pirate played by Laughton | 25 |
| Pirate played by Johnny Depp | 28 |
| Pirate pelf | 11 |
| Pirate pal | 10 |
| Pirate or Padre, for short | 26 |
| Pirate or Padre, but not an Oriole | 34 |
| Pirate or Padre, briefly | 24 |
| Pirate or Met | 13 |
| Pirate or Card, for one | 23 |
| Pirate or Brave, for short | 26 |
| Pirate on the Jolly Roger | 25 |
| Pirate of sports headlines | 26 |
| Pirate of note | 14 |
| Pirate of fiction | 17 |
| Pirate name | 11 |
| Pirate map features | 19 |
| Pirate legend Matty | 19 |
| Pirate legend Bill's nickname | 33 |
| Pirate legend | 13 |
| Pirate league | 13 |
| Pirate Lafitte | 14 |
| Pirate Laffite | 14 |
| Pirate knives | 13 |
| Pirate John and others | 22 |
| Pirate Jean | 11 |
| Pirate island off Haiti | 23 |
| Pirate interjections | 20 |
| Pirate inducted at Cooperstown in 1988 | 38 |
| Pirate in "Peter Pan" | 31 |
| Pirate in 'Peter Pan' | 29 |
| Pirate immortal | 15 |
| Pirate hideout, perhaps | 23 |
| Pirate hideout | 14 |
| Pirate hide-out, often | 22 |
| Pirate headgear | 15 |
| Pirate haven of old | 19 |
| Pirate hanged in 1701 | 21 |
| Pirate Hall of Famer | 20 |
| Pirate great Ralph | 18 |
| Pirate gold | 11 |
| Pirate from Barbary | 19 |
| Pirate foe | 10 |
| Pirate flags | 12 |
| Pirate flag in the summer sun? | 30 |
| Pirate flag icons | 17 |
| Pirate flag depiction | 21 |
| Pirate flag | 11 |
| Pirate feature | 14 |
| Pirate Edward Teach | 19 |
| Pirate drink | 12 |
| Pirate deterrent | 16 |
| Pirate Davis who is the first MLB player to hit grand slams for two different teams in the month of April | 105 |
| Pirate costume feature | 22 |
| Pirate chant starter | 20 |
| Pirate captain of legend | 24 |
| Pirate Captain | 14 |
| Pirate caches | 13 |
| Pirate booze | 12 |
| Pirate booty holder | 19 |
| Pirate booty | 12 |
| Pirate Ben of "Treasure Island" | 41 |
| Pirate battler, at times | 24 |
| Pirate battler | 14 |
| Pirate artist's activity? | 29 |
| Pirate address | 14 |
| Pirate | 6 |
| Pirata's booty | 18 |
| Piranhas in a German border river? | 34 |
| Piranhas | 8 |
| Piranha, for one | 16 |
| Piranha, e.g. | 13 |
| Piranha's place | 19 |
| Piranha predator | 16 |
| Piranha part | 12 |
| Piranha | 7 |
| Pirandello's "___ Personaggi . . . " | 50 |
| Pirandello's "Six Characters in Search ___ Author" | 64 |
| Pirandello title word | 21 |
| Pirandello and Boccherini | 25 |
| Pirandello | 10 |
| Piragua, e.g. | 13 |
| Piracy, e.g. | 12 |
| Piracy place | 12 |
| Piques, as an appetite | 22 |
| Piques at their peaks | 21 |
| Piques | 6 |
| Piquer du _____ (nose-dive) | 27 |
| Piqued states | 13 |
| Piqued state | 12 |
| Piqued | 6 |