| Pitcher Reynolds who was called "The Chief" | 53 |
| Pitcher Reynolds of the 40's-50's Yankees | 49 |
| Pitcher Reynolds of the 1940s-'50s Yankees | 46 |
| Pitcher Reynolds | 16 |
| Pitcher Randy JohnsonÂ’s power source | 40 |
| Pitcher Quisenberry | 19 |
| Pitcher Preacher | 16 |
| Pitcher plants eat them | 23 |
| Pitcher plant's snack | 25 |
| Pitcher plant victim | 20 |
| Pitcher Pettitte with a record 19 post-season wins | 50 |
| Pitcher Pettitte | 16 |
| Pitcher Peavey | 14 |
| Pitcher parts | 13 |
| Pitcher part | 12 |
| Pitcher Palmer | 14 |
| Pitcher Paige, to pals | 22 |
| Pitcher Paige, for short | 24 |
| Pitcher Paige's nickname | 28 |
| Pitcher Paige | 13 |
| Pitcher Orlando Hernández's nickname | 43 |
| Pitcher or Picon | 16 |
| Pitcher or mug parts | 20 |
| Pitcher on a basin | 18 |
| Pitcher of woo | 14 |
| Pitcher of two consecutive no-hitters Johnny Vander ___ | 55 |
| Pitcher of the Revolution | 25 |
| Pitcher of the only no-hitter in World Series history | 53 |
| Pitcher of seven no-hitters | 27 |
| Pitcher of orange juice | 23 |
| Pitcher of milk? | 16 |
| Pitcher of hoppiness? | 21 |
| Pitcher of fame | 15 |
| Pitcher of coffee? | 18 |
| Pitcher of chintzy bathroom accessories? | 40 |
| Pitcher of Borden milk? | 23 |
| Pitcher of baseball's Gas House Gang | 40 |
| Pitcher of a sort | 17 |
| Pitcher of a perfect game, 9/9/65 | 33 |
| Pitcher Nomo who was the 1995 N.L. Rookie of the Year | 53 |
| Pitcher Nomo | 12 |
| Pitcher Nolan ___ | 17 |
| Pitcher Nolan | 13 |
| Pitcher nicknamed Schoolboy | 27 |
| Pitcher nicknamed "Tornado" | 37 |
| Pitcher nicknamed "The Tornado" who threw no-hitters in 1996 and 2001 | 79 |
| Pitcher nicknamed "Bulldog" by his manager Tommy | 58 |
| Pitcher next to a plate? | 24 |
| Pitcher next to a basin | 23 |
| Pitcher Myers of the Phillies | 29 |
| Pitcher Mike with 270 wins | 26 |
| Pitcher Mike who got the win in the first and last games of the 2000 World Series | 81 |
| Pitcher Medich's nickname | 29 |
| Pitcher meas. | 13 |
| Pitcher McLain | 14 |
| Pitcher McGraw | 14 |
| Pitcher Martinez with three Cy Young Awards | 43 |
| Pitcher Martinez | 16 |
| Pitcher Mario ___ | 17 |
| Pitcher Marichal | 16 |
| Pitcher Maglie who was outdueled in Don Larsen's 1956 perfect game | 70 |
| Pitcher Maglie who in 1950 had baseball's highest winning percentage (.818) | 79 |
| Pitcher Maglie nicknamed "The Barber" | 47 |
| Pitcher Maglie and others | 25 |
| Pitcher Maglie | 14 |
| Pitcher Maddux with four Cy Young Awards | 40 |
| Pitcher Maddux who won four straight Cy Young Awards | 52 |
| Pitcher Maddux who won four consecutive Cy Young Awards | 55 |
| Pitcher Lyle | 12 |
| Pitcher Luis whose 1.60 ERA in 1968 is the lowest single-season mark in the American League since 1919 | 102 |
| Pitcher Luis for the 1970s Red Sox | 34 |
| Pitcher Luis | 12 |
| Pitcher Lopez or Vazquez | 24 |
| Pitcher like Seaver | 19 |
| Pitcher like Jack Morris | 24 |
| Pitcher like Clemens | 20 |
| Pitcher Lefty who helped popularize baseball in Japan | 53 |
| Pitcher Lefty | 13 |
| Pitcher LaLoosh's nickname in "Bull Durham" | 57 |
| Pitcher Labine of the '50s Dodgers | 38 |
| Pitcher Labine | 14 |
| Pitcher known to break down walls | 33 |
| Pitcher known as "Tom Terrific" | 41 |
| Pitcher known as "Sal the Barber" | 43 |
| Pitcher Joss | 12 |
| Pitcher Jonathan who is the Red Sox leader in saves | 51 |
| Pitcher Johnny who completes the old rhyme, "Spahn and ___ and pray for rain" | 87 |
| Pitcher Johnny and family | 25 |
| Pitcher Johnny | 14 |
| Pitcher Jim with 16 Gold Gloves | 31 |
| Pitcher Jim who was a 16-time Gold Glove winner | 47 |
| Pitcher Jim | 11 |
| Pitcher Jesse, who had the most career appearances | 50 |
| Pitcher Jesse with a record 1,252 regular-season appearances | 60 |
| Pitcher Jesse | 13 |
| Pitcher Jamie | 13 |
| Pitcher in three World Series | 29 |
| Pitcher in the first game of a playoff series, usually | 54 |
| Pitcher in many a still life | 28 |
| Pitcher in a suit? | 18 |