| "I Should Care" lyricist | 34 |
| "I should get some sleep" | 35 |
| "I should have been __ of ragged claws": Eliot | 56 |
| "I should have guessed as much" | 41 |
| "I should have known that!" | 37 |
| "I should have thought of that!" | 42 |
| "I should of ___ in bed": Joe Jacobs | 46 |
| "I should say so!" | 28 |
| "I should say __!" | 28 |
| "I should say ___!" | 29 |
| "I should think ___!" | 31 |
| "I should turn in" | 28 |
| "I should __ lucky" | 29 |
| "I should ___ die with pity" (King Lear) | 50 |
| "I should ___ die with pity": King Lear | 49 |
| "I should ___ die with pity, / To see another thus": King Lear | 72 |
| "I should ___ die with pity, / To see another thus": Shak. | 68 |
| "I should ___ lucky" | 30 |
| "I should ___!" | 25 |
| "I Should ___," 1944 hit song | 39 |
| "I Should ___," 1944 song | 35 |
| "I should've brought a sweater" | 45 |
| "I should've known better" | 40 |
| "I should've known that!" | 39 |
| "I Should've Known" singer Mann | 45 |
| "I should've known, __ ..." (Aimee Mann) | 54 |
| "I should've thought of that!" | 44 |
| "I should've worn a coat!" | 40 |
| "I shoulda guessed that" | 34 |
| "I shoulda known that!" | 33 |
| "I shoulda known that" | 32 |
| "I shouldn't have done that" | 42 |
| "I sincerely doubt that!" | 35 |
| "I Sing of ___," 15th-century carol | 45 |
| "I slept like ---" | 28 |
| "I smell ---!" | 24 |
| "I smell ---!" (sense wrong) | 38 |
| "I smell ---" | 23 |
| "I smell a ___, ___" | 30 |
| "I smell Oscar ... !" | 31 |
| "I smell __!" | 23 |
| "I smell ___!" | 24 |
| "I smell ___!" ("Something's fishy here!") | 66 |
| "I smell ___" | 23 |
| "I smell _____" | 25 |
| "I SO don't wanna hear it!" | 41 |
| "I solved it!" | 24 |
| "I sometimes hold it half ___ . . . " | 47 |
| "I sorta get it" response | 35 |
| "I speak for the trees" speaker | 41 |
| "I Spent My Summer Vacation Rolling a 300" and such? | 62 |
| "I Spy" co-star | 25 |
| "I Spy" co-star Bill, familiarly | 42 |
| "I Spy" co-star Robert | 32 |
| "I Spy" star | 22 |
| "I Spy" star Bill | 27 |
| "I Spy" TV studio | 27 |
| "I stand ___": Pasternak | 34 |
| "I Still Believe" singer Mariah | 41 |
| "I Still See __": "Paint Your Wagon" song | 61 |
| "I Still See ___" ("Paint Your Wagon" song) | 63 |
| "I Still See ___" ("Paint Your Wagon" tune) | 63 |
| "I support the motion" | 32 |
| "I support this bill" | 31 |
| "I suppose ..." | 25 |
| "I suppose it might seem odd that a reverend like myself would suddenly begin ___ ..." | 96 |
| "I suppose so" | 24 |
| "I suppose that's okay" | 37 |
| "I suppose" | 21 |
| "I surrender!" | 24 |
| "I surrender, Jose" | 29 |
| "I survived the road to Hana" island | 46 |
| "I suspected as much!" | 32 |
| "I swear . . ." | 25 |
| "I swear ..." | 23 |
| "I swear by the party of Abraham Lincoln"? | 52 |
| "I swear I won't tell ___" | 40 |
| "I swear I ___ art at all": "Hamlet" | 56 |
| "I swear it's true!" | 34 |
| "I swear it's true" | 33 |
| "I swear!" | 20 |
| "I swear, man!" | 25 |
| "I swear...!" | 23 |
| "I sympathize" | 24 |
| "I take it back" | 26 |
| "I take it that's ___" | 36 |
| "I take ___ in hand" | 30 |
| "I taught gym until they told me I was __" | 52 |
| "I taught I ___ a puddy tat!" | 39 |
| "I Taut I Taw a Puddy _____" (1950 song) | 50 |
| "I tawt I taw a puddy ---" | 36 |
| "I tawt I taw a puddy tat!" speaker | 45 |
| "I tawt I taw a puddy ___!" | 37 |
| "I tawt I taw a puddy ___" | 36 |
| "I Tawt I Taw a Puddy ___" (1950 song) | 48 |
| "I tawt I taw a putty ___" | 36 |
| "I tawt I taw a __ tat!" | 34 |
| "I tawt I ___ a puddy tat!" (Tweety's exclamation) | 64 |
| "I teach," ___ | 24 |
| "I the heir of all the . . . ": Tennyson | 50 |