| "I ___ rock from the moon..." (Talking Heads lyric) | 61 |
| "I ___ red door and I want it painted black" | 54 |
| "I ___ Men," song from "Kiss Me, Kate" | 58 |
| "I ___ Lonely" (1954 hit for the Four Knights) | 56 |
| "I ___ Little Prayer" (Dionne Warwick song) | 53 |
| "I ___ Little Prayer" (Dionne Warwick hit) | 52 |
| "I ___ like I've done this puzzle before" | 55 |
| "I ___ it out of women's faces": Shak. | 52 |
| "I ___ I've said, merely competent" (Billy Joel) | 62 |
| "I ___ Grow Up" ("Peter Pan" tune) | 54 |
| "I ___ Grow Up" ("Peter Pan" song) | 54 |
| "I ___ everything about you" Ugly Kid Joe lyric | 57 |
| "I ___ consent to die this day . . . ": Shak. | 55 |
| "I ___ Bird Now" (Antony and the Johnsons album) | 58 |
| "I ___ a drug.It's called Charlie Sheen" (that guy) | 65 |
| "I ___ a drug. It's called Charlie Sheen" | 55 |
| "I __ your long lost pal": Paul Simon lyric | 53 |
| "I __ Soldier, Too: The Jessica Lynch Story" | 54 |
| "I __ Pretty": "West Side Story" song | 57 |
| "I __ Darkness": 1999 Bonnie 'Prince' Billy album | 67 |
| "I wouldn't touch that with a ___-foot pole!" | 59 |
| "I wouldn't touch it with a ___-foot pole!" | 57 |
| "I wouldn't sit there if I were you," for example? | 64 |
| "I wouldn't go in there if I were you" | 52 |
| "I wouldn't click on this link now," initially | 60 |
| "I would like to help __ . . .": Alfred Nobel | 55 |
| "I would I had any drum of the __": Shakespeare | 57 |
| "I would give my right arm to be ambidextrous" speaker | 64 |
| "I would give all my fame for a pot of __": Shak. | 59 |
| "I Won't ___ Day Without You": Paul Williams | 58 |
| "I won't let you choke on the ___ around your neck" | 65 |
| "I won't grow up" proclaimer in a classic tale | 60 |
| "I wish you would step back from that ___, my friend" | 63 |
| "I wish you a meretricious and a happy New Year" penner | 65 |
| "I Wish I Had an Evil ___" (Magnetic Fields song) | 59 |
| "I will speak daggers to __, but use none": Hamlet | 60 |
| "I will play the ___, and die in music": Emilia | 57 |
| "I will pay more attention to my appearance," said ___ | 64 |
| "I will look on the bright side of things," said ___ | 62 |
| "I will build up my web-based business," said ___ | 59 |
| "I was worried you weren't showing up!" | 53 |
| "I was stuck in traffic at the time," e.g. | 52 |
| "I was out of town at the time of the murder," e.g. | 61 |
| "I was home asleep at the time of the murder" and others | 66 |
| "I was home alone, asleep" isn't a very good one | 62 |
| "I was getting a strange vibe from her, but ___ ..." | 62 |
| "I was freer when I didn't have __": Tyson | 56 |
| "I was caught committing a wonderfully ___..." | 56 |
| "I was at my girlfriend's at the time," and others | 64 |
| "I was at my friend's all night," e.g. | 52 |
| "I was at home sleeping at the time," e.g. | 52 |
| "I was at a movie when the crime occurred," e.g. | 58 |
| "I was at a movie theater when it happened," e.g. | 59 |
| "I Want You to Hurt Like ___" Randy Newman | 52 |
| "I want to play ___" (line from "Saw") | 58 |
| "I want to love you, ___" (Michael Jackson) | 53 |
| "I want to lay you down in a ___ of roses" | 52 |
| "I want my ___!" (old advertising catchphrase) | 56 |
| "I want in" or "I want out" indicators, maybe | 65 |
| "I Want a Big Butter and Egg Man" trumpeter | 53 |
| "I Wanna ___" (Karen Kaufman Orloff children's book) | 66 |
| "I wandered ___ a cloud . . . ": Wordsworth | 53 |
| "I vow to go out more in the evenings," said ___ | 58 |
| "I used to catch him passing notes in class" | 54 |
| "I threw away my golf shoes when I got a hole-in-one," e.g. | 69 |
| "I threw away my golf shoes when I got a hole in one," e.g. | 69 |
| "I thought ___!" ("My feeling exactly!") | 60 |
| "I thought I bought a book of puzzles, but I was..." | 62 |
| "I Think I'm ___ Here" (Carroll O'Connor memoir) | 66 |
| "I think I need ___ of execution" (Aerosmith lyric) | 61 |
| "I Think I Love You" singers (with "The") | 61 |
| "I tawt I ___ a puddy tat!" (Tweety's exclamation) | 64 |
| "I taught gym until they told me I was __" | 52 |
| "I swear I ___ art at all": "Hamlet" | 56 |
| "I swear by the party of Abraham Lincoln"? | 52 |
| "I Still See ___" ("Paint Your Wagon" tune) | 63 |
| "I Still See ___" ("Paint Your Wagon" song) | 63 |
| "I Still See __": "Paint Your Wagon" song | 61 |
| "I Spent My Summer Vacation Rolling a 300" and such? | 62 |
| "I smell ___!" ("Something's fishy here!") | 66 |
| "I should've known, __ ..." (Aimee Mann) | 54 |
| "I should ___ die with pity, / To see another thus": Shak. | 68 |
| "I should have been __ of ragged claws": Eliot | 56 |
| "I should be sleeping like a ___" (Beatles lyric) | 59 |
| "I shall not find myself so ___ die": Antony | 54 |
| "I shall love you in December ___" (Joyce) | 52 |
| "I shall be there __ you": "King Lear" | 58 |
| "I set my alarm for PM instead of AM," among others | 61 |
| "I see," in the manner of a fictional Asian detective | 63 |
| "I see," in the manner of a certain Asian detective | 61 |
| "I see," àla a certain Asian detective | 56 |
| "I say love, it is a flower, and you its only seed" song | 66 |
| "I say every member of this board is a ___..." | 56 |
| "I saw ___ sawing wood ..." (old tongue twister) | 58 |
| "I saw ___ kissing Kate" (start of a tongue twister) | 62 |
| "I saw ___ kissing Kate ..." (tongue twister) | 55 |
| "I Saw ___ Again" (1966 hit for the Mamas & the Papas) | 68 |
| "I saw --- kissing Kate..." (tongue twister) | 54 |
| "I sat in some poison ivy," said Tom _____ | 52 |
| "I refuse to join any ___ that would have me as a member" | 67 |