| Surprise victory | 16 |
| Surprise unpleasantly | 21 |
| Surprise the neighborhood? | 26 |
| Surprise test | 13 |
| Surprise tennis shot | 20 |
| Surprise Symphony composer | 26 |
| Surprise Super Bowl III winners | 31 |
| Surprise suddenly | 17 |
| Surprise success | 16 |
| Surprise strike | 15 |
| Surprise spoilers, maybe | 24 |
| Surprise spoiler, perhaps | 25 |
| Surprise smash hit movie of 1986 | 32 |
| Surprise shower? | 16 |
| Surprise selection of 2008 | 26 |
| Surprise reactions | 18 |
| Surprise quiz found in the eight longest puzzle answers | 55 |
| Surprise punt | 13 |
| Surprise police tactic | 22 |
| Surprise party command | 22 |
| Surprise party admonition | 25 |
| Surprise one's future in-laws? | 34 |
| Surprise one's costar | 25 |
| Surprise one's co-star | 26 |
| Surprise of a sort | 18 |
| Surprise nominee | 16 |
| Surprise loser of story | 23 |
| Surprise loser of 1948 | 22 |
| Surprise interjection | 21 |
| Surprise in the plot | 20 |
| Surprise in sports | 18 |
| Surprise in class | 17 |
| Surprise in a story | 19 |
| Surprise hits | 13 |
| Surprise hit, sometimes | 23 |
| Surprise hit, maybe | 19 |
| Surprise hit movie of 1986 | 26 |
| Surprise hit | 12 |
| Surprise greatly | 16 |
| Surprise giveaway? | 18 |
| Surprise gift from your tailor? | 31 |
| Surprise from Francis Marion | 28 |
| Surprise from a lamp | 20 |
| Surprise found in software and the spring | 41 |
| Surprise for the taste buds | 27 |
| Surprise for the bride | 22 |
| Surprise for a bride-to-be | 26 |
| Surprise football plays | 23 |
| Surprise fare | 13 |
| Surprise during filming | 23 |
| Surprise drop-by | 16 |
| Surprise developments | 21 |
| Surprise development | 20 |
| Surprise cries | 14 |
| Surprise court actions | 22 |
| Surprise champions, like the 1969 Mets | 38 |
| Surprise challenger | 19 |
| Surprise candidate | 18 |
| Surprise bust | 13 |
| Surprise blessing | 17 |
| Surprise birthday parties often involve them | 44 |
| Surprise birth | 14 |
| Surprise big-time | 17 |
| Surprise attacks | 16 |
| Surprise attacker | 17 |
| Surprise attack by the cops | 27 |
| Surprise attack | 15 |
| Surprise at the polls | 21 |
| Surprise at the end | 19 |
| Surprise at the door | 20 |
| Surprise at the box office | 26 |
| Surprise and then some | 22 |
| Surprise also-ran in 1948 | 25 |
| Surprise action | 15 |
| Surprise 2012 New York Knick standout Jeremy __ | 47 |
| Surprise 1990s Oscar winner | 27 |
| Surprise "from the blue" | 34 |
| Surprise | 8 |
| Surpluses | 9 |
| Surplusage | 10 |
| Surplus-water passage | 21 |
| Surplus's opposite | 22 |
| Surplus word | 12 |
| Surplus store outfit | 20 |
| Surplus store caveat | 20 |
| Surplus store | 13 |
| Surplus or vestige | 18 |
| Surplus of pleasure yachts? | 27 |
| Surplus integral to this puzzle's theme answers | 51 |
| Surplus goods | 13 |
| Surplus amount | 14 |
| Surplus | 7 |
| Surplice | 8 |
| Surpassingly good | 17 |
| Surpassing: Prefix | 18 |
| Surpassing: Comb. form | 22 |
| Surpassing in rank | 18 |
| Surpassing in quality | 21 |
| Surpassing expectations | 23 |
| Surpassing everything | 21 |