| Island or festival | 18 |
| Island or lily preceder | 23 |
| Island or port now called Xiamen | 32 |
| Island or rabbit | 16 |
| Island or terrier | 17 |
| Island or trove | 15 |
| Island ornament | 15 |
| Island over the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge | 40 |
| Island parting | 14 |
| Island party | 12 |
| Island party music source | 25 |
| Island paste | 12 |
| Island popular with tourists | 28 |
| Island porch | 12 |
| Island port | 11 |
| Island portion of Tanzania | 26 |
| Island prison for Napoleon | 26 |
| Island prison locale for Napoleon | 33 |
| Island prison of history | 24 |
| Island protector | 16 |
| Island prov. | 12 |
| Island province of the Roman Empire | 35 |
| Island purchase | 15 |
| Island purchase? | 16 |
| Island R&B derivative | 25 |
| Island reef by the Lagoon of Venice | 35 |
| Island rental | 13 |
| Island republic | 15 |
| Island republic in the Indian Ocean | 35 |
| Island republic near the Malay Peninsula | 40 |
| Island republic once called Serendip | 36 |
| Island republic ___ New Guinea | 30 |
| Island retreat for Gauguin | 26 |
| Island ring | 11 |
| Island ring? | 12 |
| Island ringlet | 14 |
| Island rings | 12 |
| Island roof material | 20 |
| Island roots | 12 |
| Island sacred to Apollo | 23 |
| Island said to be the home of Homer's tomb | 46 |
| Island seating | 14 |
| Island serenader, for short | 27 |
| Island series | 13 |
| Island setting for "Pirates of the Caribbean" | 55 |
| Island setting in Virginia Woolf's "To the Lighthouse" | 68 |
| Island settled by "Bounty" mutineers | 46 |
| Island settled by shipwrecked colonists in 1609 | 47 |
| Island shared by three nations | 30 |
| Island shared by two countries | 30 |
| Island shared by two states | 27 |
| Island shindig | 14 |
| Island show | 11 |
| Island side | 11 |
| Island side dish | 16 |
| Island singer | 13 |
| Island sleepwear? | 17 |
| Island sold in 1626 | 19 |
| Island sometimes called El Cocodrilo | 36 |
| Island song a k a "Farewell to Thee" | 46 |
| Island sorceress | 16 |
| Island south of Borneo | 22 |
| Island south of Livorno | 23 |
| Island south of Luzon | 21 |
| Island south of Martinique | 26 |
| Island south of Sicily | 22 |
| Island south of Tsugaru Strait | 30 |
| Island southeast of Borneo | 26 |
| Island southeast of Gozo and Comino | 35 |
| Island southeast of Grenada | 27 |
| Island southwest of Los Angeles | 31 |
| Island southwest of Majorca | 27 |
| Island southwest of Malaysia | 28 |
| Island souvenir | 15 |
| Island souvenirs | 16 |
| Island SSW of Naxos | 19 |
| Island staple | 13 |
| Island starch source | 20 |
| Island state | 12 |
| Island state in a 1964 merger | 29 |
| Island state of Australia | 25 |
| Island stop on a Caribbean cruise | 33 |
| Island string | 13 |
| Island strings | 14 |
| Island strings, briefly | 23 |
| Island studied by Margaret Mead | 31 |
| Island surrounding a lagoon | 27 |
| Island SW of Alaska | 19 |
| Island SW of Majorca | 20 |
| Island SW of the Battery | 24 |
| Island SW of the Philippines | 28 |
| Island SW of Timor | 18 |
| Island terrorized in ''Jaws'' | 45 |
| Island thanks | 13 |
| Island that bans autos | 22 |
| Island that processed immigrants | 32 |
| Island that the U.S. military covers nearly 30% of | 50 |
| Island that Truman wants to go to in "The Truman Show" | 64 |
| Island that will wake you up? | 29 |
| Island that's home to a state capital | 41 |