| Cookie with a rich chocolate layer | 34 |
| Cookie with a name of unknown origin | 36 |
| Cookie with a geographical name | 31 |
| Cookie with a floral design on it | 33 |
| Cookie with a filling | 21 |
| Cookie with a Double Delight variety | 36 |
| Cookie with a disgusting-sounding, limited-time watermelon flavor | 65 |
| Cookie with a crunch | 20 |
| Cookie with a creme center | 26 |
| Cookie with a creamy middle | 27 |
| Cookie with a Candy Corn variety | 32 |
| Cookie with a 1 3/4" diameter | 34 |
| Cookie whose name is also a racial slur | 39 |
| Cookie whose embossed design is trademarked | 43 |
| Cookie variety | 14 |
| Cookie used in some Klondike bars | 33 |
| Cookie used in milkshakes | 25 |
| Cookie used in cheesecake | 25 |
| Cookie units | 12 |
| Cookie unit | 11 |
| Cookie type or ingredient | 25 |
| Cookie type | 11 |
| Cookie treat since 1912 | 23 |
| Cookie treat | 12 |
| Cookie trayful | 14 |
| Cookie tidbit | 13 |
| Cookie that's one year older than crosswords | 48 |
| Cookie that's kosher | 24 |
| Cookie that's been kosher since 5758 | 40 |
| Cookie that's been around for a century | 43 |
| Cookie that turns 100 in 2012 | 29 |
| Cookie that turned 100 this past Tuesday | 40 |
| Cookie that recently celebrated its centennial | 46 |
| Cookie that received its kosher certification in late 1997 | 58 |
| Cookie that predates crosswords | 31 |
| Cookie that predates crossword puzzles | 38 |
| Cookie that once had "Sandwich" in its name | 53 |
| Cookie that often appears in crosswords | 39 |
| Cookie that now has a "cookie dough" flavor | 53 |
| Cookie that might flavor a McFlurry | 35 |
| Cookie that many take apart | 27 |
| Cookie that has its name on it | 30 |
| Cookie that debuted in 1912 | 27 |
| Cookie that comes in watermelon | 31 |
| Cookie that celebrated its centennial this year | 47 |
| Cookie that can be taken apart | 30 |
| Cookie that can be readily stacked | 34 |
| Cookie that can be divided | 26 |
| Cookie that can be "Double Stuf" | 42 |
| Cookie store? | 13 |
| Cookie store | 12 |
| Cookie spice | 12 |
| Cookie sometimes dunked in milk | 31 |
| Cookie sometimes deep-fried | 27 |
| Cookie sometimes deep fried | 27 |
| Cookie some dunk in milk | 24 |
| Cookie sold in a White Fudge version in winter | 46 |
| Cookie sold in a blue package | 29 |
| Cookie snack since 1912 | 23 |
| Cookie snack | 12 |
| Cookie site | 11 |
| Cookie since 1912 | 17 |
| Cookie similar to Hydrox | 24 |
| Cookie shop enticement | 22 |
| Cookie sheets and cake pans | 27 |
| Cookie sheetful | 15 |
| Cookie sheet graspers | 21 |
| Cookie sheet | 12 |
| Cookie shaped like two of its letters | 37 |
| Cookie served crumbled in some drinks | 37 |
| Cookie selling org., originally | 31 |
| Cookie sellers, briefly | 23 |
| Cookie sellers in green | 23 |
| Cookie sellers | 14 |
| Cookie seen in "Wreck-It Ralph" | 41 |
| Cookie sandwich | 15 |
| Cookie salesgirl, perhaps | 25 |
| Cookie recipe morsels | 21 |
| Cookie receptacle | 17 |
| Cookie quantity | 15 |
| Cookie pan | 10 |
| Cookie owned by the same company as Chips Ahoy! | 47 |
| Cookie or photo | 15 |
| Cookie on a sundae, perhaps | 27 |
| Cookie on a Domino's pizza | 30 |
| Cookie often pulled apart | 25 |
| Cookie often eaten inside-out | 29 |
| Cookie often eaten inside out | 29 |
| Cookie nut | 10 |
| Cookie nearing 100 | 18 |
| Cookie named for a Massachusetts city | 37 |
| Cookie name | 11 |
| Cookie morsel | 13 |
| Cookie Monster's usual newspaper request in N.Y.? | 53 |
| Cookie Monster's lament after bombing an English test? | 58 |
| Cookie Monster's home | 25 |
| Cookie Monster treat, maybe | 27 |
| Cookie Monster pal | 18 |
| Cookie Monster colleague | 24 |
| Cookie Monster cohort | 21 |