| New York City's first Jewish mayor | 38 |
| New York City's Carnegie ___ | 32 |
| New York City's cardinal | 28 |
| New York city with a name from antiquity | 40 |
| New York city with a famous racetrack | 37 |
| New York city where the first Woolworth's store opened | 58 |
| New York city where Ogden Nash was born | 39 |
| New York city where Mark Twain lived | 36 |
| New York city where Mark Twain is buried | 40 |
| New York city where John Jay is buried | 38 |
| New York City university | 24 |
| New York City TV station | 24 |
| New York City transportation option | 35 |
| New York City transport from the Bronx to Coney Island | 54 |
| New York City train station repairman? | 38 |
| New York City tourist attraction | 32 |
| New York City tour provider | 27 |
| New York City thoroughfare | 26 |
| New York City theater district restaurateur Vincent | 51 |
| New York City theater award | 27 |
| New York city that's home to Playland amusement park | 56 |
| New York City subway, with "the" | 42 |
| New York City suburb on the Hudson | 34 |
| New York City suburb near Yonkers | 33 |
| New York City stadium name | 26 |
| New York City stadium | 21 |
| New York City skyscraper name | 29 |
| New York City sales? | 20 |
| New York City river | 19 |
| New York City restaurateur Vincent | 34 |
| New York City rarities | 22 |
| New York City racetrack, informally | 35 |
| New York City quintet | 21 |
| New York City park name | 23 |
| New York City park | 18 |
| New York city or tribe | 22 |
| New York City or Los Angeles | 28 |
| New York city or lake | 21 |
| New York city or its college | 28 |
| New York city or county | 23 |
| New York City opera benefactor? | 31 |
| New York city on the Susquehanna | 32 |
| New York city on the Mohawk River | 33 |
| New York city on the Mohawk | 27 |
| New York City on the Hudson | 27 |
| New York city on the Allegheny River | 36 |
| New York city on the Allegheny | 30 |
| New York city on Lake Ontario | 29 |
| New York city nicknamed "City of the Hills" | 53 |
| New York City nickname ... and this puzzle's title | 54 |
| New York City nickname | 22 |
| New York City newsman Pressman | 30 |
| New York City neighborhood abutting Hell's Kitchen | 54 |
| New York city near the Pennsylvania border | 42 |
| New York city near St. Bonaventure University | 45 |
| New York city near Rome | 23 |
| New York city near Binghamton | 29 |
| New York city named for a Phoenician colony | 43 |
| New York City mayor before Ed | 29 |
| New York City mayor after John Lindsay | 38 |
| New York City Marathon winner Waitz | 35 |
| New York City Marathon sponsor | 30 |
| New York City Marathon founder Fred | 35 |
| New York city in which Mark Twain is buried | 43 |
| New York city home to the National Soccer Hall of Fame | 54 |
| New York City has six | 21 |
| New York City has one each November | 35 |
| New York City has five | 22 |
| New York City gallery locale | 28 |
| New York City Fire Museum neighborhood | 38 |
| New York city famous for silverware | 35 |
| New York city dwelling | 22 |
| New York City divisions, informally | 35 |
| New York City composition | 25 |
| New York City cardinal Edward | 29 |
| New York City cardinal | 22 |
| New York City bridge, informally | 32 |
| New York City bridge | 20 |
| New York City borough | 21 |
| New York City blackout of 1977 mayor | 36 |
| New York City avenue | 20 |
| New York City attraction | 24 |
| New York City archbishop | 24 |
| New York City and Los Angeles, e.g. | 35 |
| New York City and Kansas City | 29 |
| New York City alligator's home? | 35 |
| New York city | 13 |
| New York cathedral, familiarly | 30 |
| New York casino operators | 25 |
| New York cardinal | 17 |
| New York canal opened in 1825 | 29 |
| New York canal | 14 |
| New York cager | 14 |
| New York burg | 13 |
| New York broadsheet | 19 |
| New York bridge toll option | 27 |
| New York Botanical Garden site | 30 |
| New York borough | 16 |
| New York birthplace of Ogden Nash | 33 |
| New York birthplace of Annette Funicello | 40 |