Sidelined by injury, in baseball lingo, and a hint to how this puzzle's theme puns are formed

Question:

Length:

Similar Crossword Questions:

Temporarily not playing, in baseball lingo (and a hint to this puzzle's theme)
Hardly a model of perfection, and a hint to how this puzzle's theme puns are derived
Baseball ... with a hint to this puzzle's theme
Third base, in baseball lingo ... or a hint for answering eight other clues in this puzzle
"That's repulsive!" ... or a hint to this puzzle's theme
Nancy Reagan's antidrug slogan, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Afternoons, briefly (and hint to this puzzle's theme)
Valedictorian's pride, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
April 20th substance, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Indicators of age ... and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Disparaging name for someone who wears glasses (and a hint to this puzzle's theme)
Best Picture of 1958, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Phrase indicating slight progress, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Nine-to-five routine, and hint to this puzzle's theme
Middleman (and a hint to this puzzle's theme)
Confronting unpleasant consequences of one's actions (and a hint to this puzzle's theme)
Bartender's denial, and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Question that follows "O Brother" in film ... and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Eternal, and a hint to this puzzle's phonetic theme
Tic-tac-toe line ... and a hint to this puzzle's theme
Subject of the Final Jeopardy! question that knocked out Ken Jennings after a record 74 wins ... or a hint to this puzzle's theme
"Behave!" ... and a hint to this puzzle's theme
''Let it go!'' (and hint to this puzzle's theme)
"Shut up!" ... or a phonetic hint to this puzzle's theme
Classic 1911 children's novel ... with a hint to this puzzle's theme