Proper sort ... or a cry upon solving each of this puzzle's theme answers?

Question:

Answer:

GOODYTWOSHOES

Length:

Similar Crossword Questions:

"Gosh!" (or, based on the starts of starred answers, one who is expert at solving this puzzle's theme?)
Reverend whose name is linked to terms like "Pazz and Jop," and this puzzle's theme answers
Numerator for this puzzle's theme answers
Classic breakup line, and a hint to the formation of this puzzle's theme answers
What each completed pair of theme answers in this puzzle is
Surplus integral to this puzzle's theme answers
Easy, and what this puzzle's theme answers literally are
Wise guys featured in this puzzle's theme answers
Attendance check, and a hint to the puzzle theme in the first words of the starred answers
1997 Kevin Kline film, and a hint to the puzzle theme hidden in four answers
The pairs of letters inserted into each of this puzzle's theme answers, for example
Tip, and a hint to this puzzle's theme found in five answers
What the puzzlemaker did to the name in each of this puzzle's theme answers?
Nanobot's hypothetical ability, and the process that's overtaken this puzzle's theme answers
Supplements added to each of this puzzle's theme answers
Rumored reason for the stock market plunge of 5/6/10, whose effect is seen in this puzzle's theme answers
New element in each of this puzzle's theme answers
Structure of this puzzle's theme, hidden in five answers
Rebelliously, perhaps (and a hint to this puzzle's four theme answers)
Rhyme runaway, and how this puzzle's theme answers are formed?
Agent "embedded" in this puzzle's theme answers
Finding from the "fifths" taken from this puzzle's theme answers
They swing up and down in this puzzle's theme answers
It's soft, strong, and demonstrated by this puzzle's four theme answers
Nabisco cookies ... and what you might cry upon solving this puzzle's three other longest answers?