Baffling puzzle - Answers with 5 to 6 Letters

Question:

Baffling puzzle

Answer:

2 possible answers to

Answers with 5 characters:

POSER

Answers with 6 characters:

ENIGMA

Similar Crossword Questions:

"___ is completely over" (baffling statement made by Prince on 7/5/10 that also serves as a clue how to find four answers in this puzzle)
Film star celebrated in this puzzle
Adds up ... like this puzzle's theme?
Rebus puzzle conjunction
Theme of today's puzzle
What the puzzlemaker did to the name in each of this puzzle's theme answers?
Break, briefly ... or a hint to this puzzle's theme
Mate, and a hint to the starts of this puzzle's four longest answers
Puzzle answers
1937 Best Picture nominee (and what you might shout after finishing this puzzle)
Logical connection hidden in eight puzzle answers
Summer blazer, which can come before the starts of this puzzle's four longest answers
"Superman" publisher, and this puzzle's title
What a well-written sudoku puzzle never requires you to do
This puzzle's theme, whose first notes are indicated by shaded squares
Partially obscured (and a hint to this puzzle's theme)
Picnic serving, and when divided properly, a hint to a hidden feature of six pairs of puzzle answers
Puzzle book offering
Its common extensions are the theme of this puzzle
Comedy writer Carol (whose new book, "How to Succeed in Business Without Really Crying," inspired this puzzle)
September 8, 1974 pard recipient - and what the constructor did throughout this puzzle
Ocean "crossing" this puzzle's four longest answers (abbr.)
Heart of a London puzzle?
Noted box opener (that, curiously, will tell you what to put in six of this puzzle's boxes when read with the enumeration 1 3/2 1)
Like some words in this puzzle