Possible Questions:
- Jewel
- Sweetheart
- Prize
- Valuable rock
- Treasure
- Nonpareil
- Precious stone
- Pip
- Standout
- Beaut
- Sparkler
- Masterpiece
- Beauty
- Brilliant
- Emerald, for one
- Prized possession
- Take ___ (rest)
- Birthstone
- Diamond
- Muffin
- Valuable find
- Shining example
- Ring thing
- Ring rock
- Ring feature
- Kind of muffin
- Its place is in a setting
- Cameo, e.g.
- Setting item
- Ring item
- Ornamental stone
- Diamond or ruby
- Tiara feature
- Ruby, for one
- Ruby, e.g.
- Rare find
- Kind of shoe
- Emerald, e.g.
- Bijou
- Any birthstone
- Special person
- Sherlock's Blue Carbuncle, for one
- Opal or onyx
- Marvel
- Fine stone
- Cameo
- What carats measure
- Valuable stone
- Thing on a ring
- Thing of beauty
- Ruby or garnet
- Ring stone
- Peach
- Lapidarist's item
- Emerald or ruby
- Bit of treasure
- Tourmaline, e.g.
- Tiffany treasure
- Tanzanite, e.g.
- Stone with facets
- Something prized
- Solitaire, e.g.
- Ruby or emerald
- Rock on a ring
- Ring insert
- Priceless joke
- Precious thing
- Precious item
- Peridot, e.g.
- Lapidary item
- Jewelry stone
- Its setting is a setting
- It goes in a setting
- Glittering valuable
- Columbia, in a song
- Cat's-eye, e.g.
- Birth-month symbol
- Baguette, for one
- Aquamarine, e.g.
- Amethyst, e.g.
- Tourmaline or amethyst, e.g.
- Topaz or ruby
- Thing in a ring?
- Stellar sort
- Solitaire
- Shiny stone
- Setting sight
- Setting filler
- Ring part
- Prized rock
- Prized person
- Little beauty
- Lapidary's concern
- It may be cut or paste
- Emerald or pearl
- Diamond, pearl or sapphire
- Diamond or emerald
- Cut stone
- Blue carbuncle, e.g.
- Bit of finery
- Beloved person
- Baguette, e.g.
- Amethyst, for one
- Amethyst or tourmaline
- Word for a good domestic
- Wonderful person, as it were
- Turquoise or topaz, e.g.
- Turquoise or topaz
- Turquoise or aquamarine, e.g.
- Treasured person
- Treasure chest item
- Tourmaline or peridot
- Tourmaline or amethyst
- Topaz or turquoise
- Tiara component
- There's one hidden in the answer to each starred clue
- The Blue Carbuncle, to Holmes
- Terrific person
- Stony sparkler
- Stone that's "cut" in this puzzle's four longest answers
- Star of India, e.g.
- Special someone
- Sparkling stone
- Sparkler?
- Sparkler on a crown
- Something sparkling
- Small wonder
- Small masterpiece
- Setting stone
- Setting fill
- Scarab or cameo
- Sapphire. e.g.
- Sapphire, e.g.
- Ruby or topaz
- Rock with a band?
- Rock with a band
- Rock in hock, often
- Real peach
- Real find
- Real beauty
- Rare one
- Rare beauty
- Rare album
- Prized stone
- Prized object
- Prized asset
- Peridot or tigereye
- Perfect thing
- Perfect instance
- Pearl or ruby
- Opal or garnet
- Onyx, e.g.
- Onyx or opal
- No-hitter, e.g.
- Multifaceted sparkler
- Mountain ___ (green hummingbird)
- Little treasure
- Little masterwork
- Little masterpiece
- Lapis lazuli e.g.
- Lapidary's interest
- Lapidarist's object of study
- Jeweler's item
- Jewel or muffin
- It's placed in a setting
- It's often seen ringside
- It's multifaceted
- It might be examined with a loupe
- It may be set
- It has its setting
- It has facets
- Idaho, the -- State
- Idaho, the ___ State
- Hope Diamond, for one
- Highly prized person
- Highly prized item
- Heck of a person
- Great prize
- Great pitching effort, as it were
- Great find
- Garnet or ruby
- Garnet or peridot
- Fabergé-egg adornment
- Expensive stone
- Expensive sparkler
- Emerald or sapphire
- Definite keeper
- Crown ornament
- Crown component
- Columbia, vis-a-vis the ocean
- Columbia, in anthem
- Cat's-eye or sard
- Cat's-eye
- Cabochon, e.g.
- Brilliant, e.g.
- Beautiful example
- Archer of Oasis
- Absolute beauty
- "Columbia, the ___ of the Ocean" (old patriotic song)